The Rusted Monument

Secret Pittsburgh

The Rusted Monument

The road that takes you down to the Carrie Furnaces is newly built, slipping quietly off of South Braddock Avenue before you get on the Rankin Bridge. This almost mile stretch to the site offers pristine views of the Monongahela River and has been reclaimed by the earth. As you reach the site and park in the lot made out front by chain link fence there’s a silence about the place. The tall red buildings loom over you, a piece of history frozen and decaying. Everywhere that rust has taken apart new plants grow through it. It is hard to imagine now the chaos of being in this exact spot a century ago or even forty years ago as countless steel workers continued to make take in train cars of ore and coke and return them full of the liquid steel. The Carrie Furnaces are a place for reverie, one of the last portals into such a past that we have left in the country. Yet this place feels like something more than that, this place is a monument to the people of Pittsburgh, an icon of the Monongahela Valley.

This idea stems from Pittsburgh’s pride for its work in the industrial era. As one of the largest steel producers during the height of Andrew Carnegie and Henry Clay Frick, it is not hard to see how much the mills would have impacted the lives of those who worked there. In the Monongahela Valley especially the shells of former and still active mills rise high over the rows of houses and small businesses that scatter the hillside, they are visible from almost everywhere in these neighborhoods. Even the Waterfront complex across the river cannot detract from the sheer size of these old remnants of industry far off in the distance.

Besides the physical presence of these places there is a certain attitude of the people of Pittsburgh, a deep pride in this kind of work despite its danger. In my own visit to the Carrie Furnaces I was lucky enough to be guided by a man named Tom. As an educator and former blast furnace worker he knew the place well and had great insight in both the way a place like this runs as well as what life is like for those that work there. His stories were grandiose, telling of immense struggle and grueling work as well as camaraderie between the workers. Despite all this, there was laughter in his voice and light in his eyes. But this is not new, generations before Tom men were working at the Homestead Steel Mill and even during the time of the infamous Homestead Strike there was a pride in the work being done there. In the telling novel Out of This Furnace by Thomas Bell, second generation mill worker Mike Dobrjcak is quoted saying “If they’d let me I could love that mill like something of my own. It’s a terrible and beautiful thing to make iron. It’s honest work, too, work the world needs (Bell, 195-196).” Making steel is exhausting and often times life threatening, but these men were carrying the world on their shoulders and proudly propelled us into a new age.

After the furnaces shut down in 1978, however, Pittsburgh was shifting away from this industrial work with the decline of the steel industry. As the facility lay empty there was much dispute about what to do with the acres of property that the Homestead Mill occupied. In his book Twentieth-Century Pittsburgh, Roy Lubove discusses the problems of re-development after the Park Corporation had bought the land in 1988. “The overwhelming emphasis on jobs (and the remaining legacy of coke and steel in Braddock, West Mifflin, and Clairton) has discouraged alternative developments of community development (39).” A team of architects had proposed that the land be turned into a community space, including an outdoor space for garden festivals, a flea market, and a racetrack. These ideas were not received well by those in the area, both out of work and struggling to support themselves. This put the Carrie Furnaces in a gridlock, stuck between its grand past and the fast approaching future (Lubove, 38-40).

In 2005 the land was bought again by Allegheny County and with efforts from the Steel Industry Heritage Council and other organizations the place was deemed a National Historic Landmark. With the dispute between what to do with the mill compromised, the people of Pittsburgh had a place to reflect on their past.

his notion of reflection can be seen throughout the Carrie Furnaces. On the guided tours you are taken to all parts of the facility to see how the ores were brought and melted in order to create the liquid steel sent to the Homestead Mill. But even in the modern era people have found use for this place. Since it’s re-opening to the public the Carrie Furnaces have put on tons of events and concerts as well as hosted art classes of all kinds. Graffiti and sculpture can be found throughout the grounds hidden in plain sight. This kind of creativity is helping bring more attention to the blast furnaces, and in turn helping people understand their past better. In Thomas Sweterlitch’s novel Tomorrow and Tomorrow Pittsburgh is a wasteland. People use virtual reality to re-visit their lives and study the catastrophe through archived footage and pictures of the area. In one of our first encounters with the Archive the main character John Blaxton says “There are others on this bus, others visiting the Archive – we’re different from the illusions, somehow lighter. We all look at one another, wondering what we’ve lost (Sweterlitsch, 25).”

While the ideas in Sweterlitch’s novel are dreary this is a good way to understand what being at the Carrie Furnaces are like. Whether you are there to get in touch with your past or to connect with the space through art and entertainment there is a sense of stillness from those early industrial days. Here we can learn about histories danger and beauty through what is remembered. The Carrie Furnaces have become a place to reflect on our past while engaging with the modern day. This silence and beauty has great importance and allows the Carrie Furnaces to become a true monument to the Monongahela Valley and the City of Pittsburgh.