Reminders of Home: A Trip through an Alternate Pittsburgh

Secret Pittsburgh

Reminders of Home: A Trip through an Alternate Pittsburgh

My name is Hanna and I’ve lived in Pittsburgh my whole life. I have observed many changes to the city’s cultural district from its beginnings as a former red-light district to the present day (Pittsburgh Cultural Trust). Watching the neighborhood change into a beautiful arts district inspired me to participate in the arts as I grew up. I was a huge fan of the shows that were held at the Benedum Center theater and the art and other exhibits along Liberty Ave. My favorite location in the district currently is the 820 Liberty Gallery. It is bright and open with each exhibit having its own unique arrangement within the space, giving the gallery a new feel every time. Over the years, I have attended many of the Cultural Trust’s “gallery crawls,” which have helped me to feel even more connected to the history of art in Pittsburgh (Pittsburgh Cultural Trust). My most recent visit to the gallery changed my perspective on the city I thought I had always known. The exhibit that day was titled: “Frank Lloyd Wright’s Southwestern Pennsylvania: The Pittsburgh Projects.” It was an exhibit of the plans that Edgar J. Kaufmann and Frank Lloyd Wright drafted together to reimagine downtown Pittsburgh, complete with models, architectural sketches of plans, and a film showing drone-like footage of what downtown would have looked like if the plans had been realized.

Stepping into the exhibit, I was met by bright walls and the drawings and rendered images of Wright’s envisioned Civic Center. There was quiet, triumphant music playing throughout the gallery. To my right, I could see a model of the Kaufmann self-service parking garage, illuminated by the large front windows of the gallery space. The model sat on a pink pedestal covered with a glass case, and it revealed the six levels of parking that Wright had envisioned. “The Kaufmann Self Service Parking Garage was designed to have six levels plus one underground level to hold over 1200 cars” (Pfeiffer). The model was so detailed that it seemed to grow larger inside the glass case, the longer I looked at it. Reality seemed to fade out until, suddenly, I was there in the waiting room inside Frank Lloyd Wright’s plan. I cautiously walked into the central part of the garage where a fountain sat, surrounded by department store windows showing Kaufmann’s products. It was very quiet and almost eerie with no people around. I expected to hear the frenzied sound of cars trying to navigate in and out of the garage through clusters of traffic, but I was met with only a subtle breeze through the open layers of the structure. It was as if Wright and Kaufmann were able to make the dream a reality, and they were simply waiting on a few final touches before opening the space to the public. I felt panicked, trying to think of a way to get back to the gallery, back to the Pittsburgh I have always known and loved, and I found myself walking up the slanted road that wrapped around the garage searching for an exit from this alternative reality. After what felt like hours, I noticed a faint image hidden in the texture of the concrete walls. It appeared to be a face, covered partially by shadow. Then, finally, I recognized it as the symbol of the Pittsburgh Cultural Trust: a stylized version of a theater mask. I must be on the right track! This must be my way home. It was so familiar to me that I instinctively reached out towards the design, and then the 820 Liberty Gallery materialized around me, my hand still reaching towards the model of the garage in front of me. That was odd. I shook it off, thinking I had simply been engrossed in the model and fell into it as if in a daydream. Still, I enjoyed envisioning that alternate reality of Pittsburgh that Wright had planned.

To the right of the parking garage, but still in the open, main space, was the model and description of the Point View residences which would have been constructed on Mount Washington. The model showed the triangular building (GLM) constructed into the hillside, looking over the city. The description was as follows: “The Point View residences were apartments constructed for the Edgar J. Kaufmann Charity Trust” (McCarthy). And, yet again, I found myself suddenly standing in one of the apartments as if taking a step into a new world entirely. The apartment was huge, seeming to endlessly expand in a triangular fashion out from the center. Again, the space felt new and never lived in, like it, too, was waiting for some “go ahead” signal to even exist. I walked slowly over to a window, careful not to disturb any of the staging, and found myself looking out across the Monongahela. It was beautiful to see the city from this angle, even if the way the building stuck out from the hillside made me uneasy. I started looking for a symbol like the one from the parking garage that might help me find my way back home, back to reality, again. After what felt like ages of searching, I found the Trust’s symbol in the wood grain of a coffee table at the center of the apartment. By reaching out towards the symbol, I was once again standing in the gallery next to the model, with my hand outstretched.Okay, now this has happened twice, what’s going on?

Continuing into the back section of the 820 Liberty Gallery, I was stunned to see how the space was being used for the current exhibit. The back section’s walls were a dark grey and a stark contrast against the bright, neutral color of the front of the space. The lights were much dimmer in the back, creating a cinematic feel. There was a wall separating the two halves of the gallery, which stretched across the middle of the room guiding the path visitors took through the space. The source of the music I had heard before became clear as I entered the dim back area where a film was being projected onto the wall that separated the two sections of the gallery. The film displayed drone-like footage of the Wright’s imagined Civic Center and what it would have looked like if it had been built downtown. Once again, I felt myself dragged towards the film, only this time I wasn’t standing inside a building but, rather, suspended in the sky. I swung my arms wildly, trying to slow a fall that I soon realized wasn’t happening as I remained floating above the Civic Center. It appeared below me as a terraced orb, towering next to the business district of downtown from its location where Point State Park is today (City Journal). From my bird’s eye view, I could see a large skylight that lit the space from the top floors all the way to the bottom floor at the very center of the building. There were no cars on the roads around the structure, and the usual hustle and bustle of downtown traffic was nowhere to be seen or heard. I found myself searching out the recognizable three rivers that sectioned off the Point, the Monongahela, Ohio, and Allegheny. There were two “new” bridges spanning the Monongahela and the Allegheny that were much more modern and not like the bridges that make up Pittsburgh today with their iconic yellow and industrial feel. My mind drifted back to the bridges I have known my entire life and how much they represent the city. Memories flooded my mind, and the Civic Center started to disappear until I felt myself falling back into the 820 Gallery.

When leaving the Gallery, I thought about how different Pittsburgh would have been if Kaufmann’s and Wright’s designs had been realized. It made me think about all the things that make Pittsburgh the city I know today, with its iconic bridges and rich history. The symbol of the Cultural Trust was one that I had seen many times throughout the years as I went to art shows and performances at the 820 Liberty Gallery, and it was what brought me back to the city that I know. The 820 Gallery has always held a special place in my heart, and today it showed me just how powerful art can be for imagining change and reminding wanderers of home.

Works Cited

“Background & History.” Trustarts.org, trustarts.org/pct_home/about/history. Accessed 12 Apr. 2026.

Bruce Brooks Pfeiffer, and Frank Lloyd Wright. Treasures of Taliesin : Seventy-Seven Unbuilt Projects. San Francisco, Pomegranate, 1999.

“Frank Lloyd Wright’s Dream Cities.” City Journal, 23 Mar. 2023, www.city-journal.org/article/frank-lloyd-wrights-dream-cities. Accessed 17 Apr. 2026.

Gerald Lee Morosco Architects. “Frank Lloyd Wright: Pointview Realized.” GLM 1, 2026, glm-architects.com/fllw-pointview. Accessed 17 Apr. 2026.

McCarthy, Jeremiah. “Frank Lloyd Wright’s Southwestern Pennsylvania – the Westmoreland Museum of American Art.” The Westmoreland Museum of American Art, 19 Oct. 2023, thewestmoreland.org/blog/frank-lloyd-wrights-southwestern-pennsylvania/. Accessed 12 Apr. 2026.