Allentown (“Little Salem”)

Secret Pittsburgh

Photo by Jacob Daly, 2026.

Allentown (“Little Salem”)

Location Information

Address: 746-753 E Warrington Ave

Website: Visit website

Admission: Free

Up the hill from the bustling atmosphere and bright lights of Pittsburgh’s South Side, there sits a less well-known (but equally charming) corner of the city called Allentown. Bounded by the physical geography of the slopes and Beltzhoover Avenue, Allentown, like many other neighborhoods in Pittsburgh, may seem at first glance to be past its prime and reflective of the city’s physical and social changes after a regional decline in the steel industry. However, that state of decline could not be further from the truth.  

Named after butcher Joseph Allen, who purchased the land upon which the neighborhood now sits, Allentown was settled primarily by German immigrants, with local architecture that continues to reflect this heritage today. The late nineteenth century saw quick development for the neighborhood due to its convenient location to downtown and because of more than a dozen inclines in the area that transported people, coal, and other products up and down Pittsburgh’s hilly infrastructure. 

Recently, and especially within the last couple of years, Allentown has come to be known by locals and enthusiasts of the macabre as the “Little Salem” of Pittsburgh. The neighborhood has earned this reputation because it is home to a budding alternative gothic culture, exemplified by several small, nascent businesses mostly gathered along the main thoroughfare of East Warrington Avenue. Collectively, these businesses aim to provide a supportive space for Pittsburgh’s alternative aesthetic and culture. 

Four businesses stand out as the heart of “Little Salem.” The first is a corner coffee shop called “Grim Wizard Coffee.” This eccentric, heavy metal-themed coffee shop serves, dare we say, enchanted coffee and assorted beverages in Allentown. Lining the walls of the coffee shop, metal adornments and band memorabilia draw the attention of any passerby interested in good music and a caffeine fix. Chad Hammitt, the owner, expressed his care for the Allentown community and plans to expand food offerings soon. He also happens to be married to Kelly Branden, the owner of the antiques and oddities shop next door, “Weeping Glass.” Kelly organizes the “Allentown Night Market” and helped to foster Allentown’s transformation into a macabre tourist destination. Other local and family-owned businesses of “Little Salem” include Natalie Linaweaver’s “Wonder Witch Company,” which thematically merges classic literature and witchcraft, and Jesse Mader’s “Storyville Lounge at Dr. Tumblety’s,” which features a distillery, oddities shop, and speakeasy bar and lounge all in one! Named after Francis Tumblety, a primary suspect in the Jack the Ripper case, the store has multiple hidden bars that serve its house-distilled alcohol. 

Works Cited

Blackley, Katie. “Adventure through Colorful and Historic Allentown.” 90.5 WESA, WESA, 22 May 2020, http://www.wesanews.org/arts-sports-culture/2020-05-22/adventure-through-colorful-and-historic-allentown.

“Grim Wizard Coffee.” Grim Wizard Coffee, http://www.grimwizard.com

Accessed 20 Nov, 2026

“The Storyville Lounge.” Inspired by Spirits, inspiredbyspirits.com/storyvillelounge/.

Accessed 20 Nov, 2026.

“The Weeping Glass.” The Weeping Glass, http://www.theweepingglass.com

Accessed 20 Nov, 2026

“Wonder Witch Company.” Wonder Witch Boutique, http://www.wonderwitchboutique.com

Accessed 20 Nov, 2026