Reinventing a Derelict Space

Secret Pittsburgh

Reinventing a Derelict Space

Almost weekly, I can be found driving across the Homestead Grays Bridge on my way to the Waterfront, in Homestead, PA (waterfrontpgh.com). The Waterfront has a plethora of stores for general shopping, high-end eateries and fast-food favorites, as well as general-needs stores for groceries and home repair; in a sense, it has it all. It’s no wonder I find myself there too often. As I make my familiar journey across the river, I never used to give much thought to what I was traveling over, or where exactly I was going. The bridge gives me access to Homestead, separated from Squirrel Hill by the Monongahela River, and I am going to pick up necessary supplies (or maybe just to spend a few extra dollars). End of story, right? Not quite. Through my tour of the Carrie Blast Furnace and further research, I have come to discover that this routine of mine is not the end of the story, in fact, it is just a random sentence, paragraph maybe, in the grand story of Pittsburgh, its people, and its history. After visiting the furnace and realizing just how close I was to raw history (the Waterfront sits on land formally known as the Homestead Steel works, Homestead Steel Works), I looked for her one day on my way over the bridge, and I saw Carrie, clear as day. How had I missed this incredible sight in the past when it was so obvious now? Sounds like a no-brainer of course, that I am but a small part in the big picture, but I attempt to use this common idea to tell a new story of Pittsburgh’s important industrial history, of how it is living on today through the artwork and support of its people, and how the work of those supporters is promoting and refining the true beauty that is held within the confines of the Carrie Blast Furnace.

Theorist Edward Soja gives insight to a discussion of space, space that is real and inhabited (the Waterfront stores), and space that is imagined or filling the air essentially (the history of Homestead and surrounding areas). Soja presents two trialectics to explain the conjunction of these two states of space, a “thirdspace,” the Trialectic of Being and the Trialectic of Spatiality (Soja). The Trialectic of Being depicts how humans are or “how we humans ‘be’,” and contains three categories: Historicality, Sociality, and Spatiality (Soja). Historicality explains the idea of progress and repetition, Sociality considers emotions and mental states or “societal aspects,” and Spatiality represents the space of these instances, but as more than the physicality of the space. The Trialectic of Spatiality is an expansion of this last theory from trialectic #1, and it includes three more categories that interact with each other: Perceived, Conceived, and Lived (Soja). These categories of space each have a separate meaning, but they exist within each other, helping Soja explain his position on “thirdspace.” “Firstspace” is the perceived space, the physical and measureable object, “secondspace” is the conceived space that depicts the imagined and ideational projections in the perceived space, and lastly, his “thirdspace” is the lived space that essentially combines the previous categories in an attempt to explain how we use this space and how it affects us (Soja). Using Soja’s theory, I present a story about the use of space at the furnaces, both in its historicality and its spatiality.

When describing Manhattan, Michel de Certeau details the space of the big picture of the city, the “urban island’ of skyscrapers, and the feeling of seeing this grand space from above, on the top floor of one of those skyscrapers. He also lends information about the true feel of the city, and how visuals of those grand buildings can blur the perceptions of what is actually happening: “The gigantic mass is immobilized before the eyes. It is transformed into a texturology in which extremes coincide – extremes of ambition and degradation, brutal oppositions of races and styles, contrasts between yesterday’s buildings, already transformed into trash cans, and today’s urban irruptions that block out its space” (Certeau). It is easy to draw a connection between his explanation of space and Soja’s terms of space; the perception of the city is in its impressive architecture, and the conceived space explains how the mind can be swept up in the aroma of this majestic city, but the lived space, the “thirdspace,” provides the elucidation of how this skewed reality affects everyday life, with the degradation of historical space. My story paints a similar picture, one that explains how the space of the Carrie Blast Furnace is being shaped by the perceived and conceived spaces, therefore creating a new lived space. The relics of the past, those towering blast furnaces, are no longer mentally covered in dust, as present-day people are working toward the preservation and restoration of the historical site.

The Carrie Blast Furnace officially closed in 1982, and went largely untouched until 2006 when it became a National Historic Landmark and restoration work commenced. Before this new attention came to the furnaces, a small group of guerilla artists found a space rich with history and potential. In 1997, this group of Pittsburgh artists went to great lengths to create a piece of art that has since become one of the main points in the drive for revitalization. The impressive structure that remains from these artists has been dubbed the “Carrie Deer” (The Carrie Deer), and stands as the first work of “industrial salvage” at the furnace (Baraff). Rising 40 feet above the deteriorating structures of the furnace, and created from site ruins, the Carrie Deer is a pivotal entity of the revitalization of the furnace. The Deer’s artists mimicked the hard, grueling work that was featured at the site more than a decade before their arrival, taking this place of the past and making it their own. Their nod to the historical use of the site was the use of the Blast Furnace’s own raw material in the making of the deer, and their own interpretation of the degradation of the site, that of wild nature taking it back, was the deer. The Deer sparked the revolution of art that is now an integrated part of the Carrie restoration. For several years now, the site has been a desired setting for “independent and mainline movie production as well as performance, art, music, and photography groups” (Baraff). Many different types of art can be found at the site, and upon visiting the actual grounds, one can be swept up in the aura that Carrie now creates. Once a site known for its exhausting and dangerous work, is now a site of adventure and excitement as well as raw history. The perceived space is most certainly that of post-industrial remains and the overgrowth of nature, but the work of present artists and preservationists are creating a conceived space of opportunity and light, in the face of the isolated uninhabited, and a new lived space that allows the site to inspire the visitor to commemorate its historical significance and view how present restoration efforts both preserve and transform the space.

In 2012, after more than 30 years of darkness, the Carrie Blast Furnace was re-lit for a special event that gathered locals and those from afar to tour the grounds of past familiar operations and witness iron flowing for one last time (The Iron Garden Walk) (Erdley). Directors of this event sought to create a connection with the past, while facilitating growth in the future, by conducting an iron pour to commemorate the past. This effort by the Rivers of Steel National Heritage Area attempted to garner public support of their restoration and preservation work at the site. In attendance were artists, former blast furnace workers, families of former workers, and those who had personal connections with the site from its heyday. The event allowed for master gardeners and artists to work alongside steel sculptors and students, those professions that would otherwise not be seen together, all working toward the same ultimate goal (Leeman). This gathering continues to keep the fire ablaze, one that was ignited from the original spark of the Carrie Deer. This assemblence of the public was not the last of its kind, as the Rivers of Steel and those backing the Carrie Blast Furnace host many performances and other gatherings at the site. One such event was the daylong performance by “The Pillow Project,” a dance company that performed at the furnace in 2013. The performance included “improvisational jazz dance, along with live music, video projection, art installations, and more” presented as “The Jazz Furnace” (Bauknecht). Pearlann Porter, director of the dance company, was excited about the opportunity to perform at a site so packed with history, mentioning that while she did not have any ties to the furnace or steelwork, she wanted to “connect to it somehow” (Bauknecht). During the performance, former steelworkers and caretakers of the site were available to answer questions about the Carrie’s history, making that connection to the past ever present. Porter also said she wants people to “reconsider these leftover relics of Pittsburgh’s past,” which I imagine is exactly the kind of attention that those who support restoration of the furnace are striving to obtain (Bauknecht).

Other performance art or art installations featured at the site include work by Alloy Pittsburgh (Alloy Pittsburgh), a visual and performing arts project founded by Pittsburgh artists and developed in collaboration with the Rivers of Steel National Heritage Area (Leeman). This organization has sought to use the site as a way to further understand Pittsburgh and the history of the city. The artists are there to spend time creating and investing in what the place is and was; in this way they have the ability to internalize the space more than a regular tour. The founders, Sean Derry and Chris McGinnis, hope that by looking at the site through an art practice, they are providing a unique way to think about the future and an element that can tie the community to the site outside of iron-making (Leeman). Less of a production, and more of a staple piece of the site, are the numerous splashes of graffiti found around the walls of the site. While not all of those marks were personally invited by Rivers of Steel to express creation and breathe new life into the site, they still stand as a significant piece in the transformation of the furnace. Featured along with the guerilla graffiti are the wildflowers and fields of grass. In a place that used to carry “deafening sounds of rail cars booming and banging and sirens and whistles blowing,” there are now the peaceful noises of nature, birds and crickets (Erdley).

Charles Rumford Walker, a graduate of Yale College who resigned a commission as first lieutenant in the U.S. Army in order to go work in the brute-force end of the steel industry, kept a personal diary during his days as a steelworker and eventually published his collection of thoughts in his book, “Steel, The Diary of a Furnace Worker.” In the foreword of his narrative, he describes steel as a basic industry of America, the industry that “props our complex industrial civilization” (Walker). He went on to explain that he believed the steel industry, along with coal, was specifically “cast for leading roles either in the breaking-up or the making-over of society” (Walker). I clung to this particular passage because I believe it was telltale of his future, our past, of the city of Pittsburgh, that of how the steel industry propped up the city and brought thousands of foreigners seeking work, as well as how when it ended it left Pittsburgh cut open. This one sentence presented by Walker brings history full circle, as shown by the breaking of families through hard conditions in the furnaces, the breaking of city morale through labor strikes and battles, and the decline of the workforce at the end of the steel era. The city’s history was then brought back up by the efforts of local artists and preservationists seeking to create a make-over of society, maybe not in its entirety, but at least in its perception of the space at the Carrie Blast Furnace. The Carrie Blast Furnace was born with a certain perceived space, and continues into the future with the same genetic make-up of an industrial structure, but energy felt now at the furnace, through the help of the Rivers of Steel National Heritage Area and eager artists, ensures that the conceived space allows for peace, reflection, and wonder, and the lived space, the “thirdspace,” will positively influence Pittsburgh for generations to come.